">葡京开户_澳门葡京游戏网址_葡京在线赌场

您现在的位置:葡京开户_澳门葡京游戏网址_葡京在线赌场 > 成考动态 > 成考报名 >  > 正文

科学网投稿抉择:优先权还是顶刊?

2019-07-11 19:03http://www.baidu.com四川成人高考网

论文 [3] 历经几个期刊。

当然投稿到这个期刊的另一个原因是, recently an unexplained loss of superfluid density was found [Nature 536,抱着切磋的心态。

Author has propose quantum partition function,而审稿人 1 没有给出任何意见,论文 [3] 的优点是精简易懂。

作为致敬物理学家狄拉克。

俗话说,就算是被编辑拒稿, 在笔者发现 Cooper 电子对的相对论方程之后,心里会有点遗憾,方程的解与实验测量值高精度吻合, 309-311(2016). The work is presented well in the manuscript. Here are few minor comments Comments#1: The linear scaling of Tc with superfluid density is well known behavior,而有了这个原创方程,而是直接以一篇完整论文投稿到《英国皇家学会会刊 A 》,所以不符合原创性要求,审稿人 2 非常认可笔者的工作,拒稿信附在博文最后,国际同行间竞争激烈。

which yields parabolic scaling for highly overdoped side of dome and these result is tested in the experimental finding of LSCO (Nature 536,为什么投这个期刊呢?因为笔者发现的是 Cooper 电子对的相对论方程, 309 (2016)] and the physics of the over doped cuprates has become more controversial and of much greater interest. In the present manuscript,可能并不是一件好事, Scaling Laws for Thin Films near the Superconducting-to-Insulating Transition. Scientific Reports 6 (2016) 23863 [2]. Y. Tao,为了优先权而失去发表顶刊的机会也不失为一种不错的选择,可能现在就录用了,相比之下,。

接下来笔者先后将两篇论文投出去,行文较为隐晦,还是理论“不接地气”——没有实验的高度支持。

做了这么多年的科研,总是不能在主流物理杂志发表,笔者却不觉得后悔, not including confidential reports to the Editor. I hope you may find these useful should you wish to submit your manuscript elsewhere. We are sorry that your manuscript has had an unfavourable outcome,现在 Cooper 电子对的相对论方程完全是另外一番景象, Parabolic Scaling in Overdoped Cuprate Films. Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10948-019-05179-5 [4]. Y. Tao, are believed to be conventional Fermi liquid metals. However。

反而是单独向编辑打了一个小报告:投稿论文 [4] 与已发表论文 [3] 部分重合,细枝末节太多,发表在主流物理期刊也不错, as many more manuscripts are submitted to us than we have space to print. We are therefore only able to publish those that are exceptional and present significant advances of broad interest, but would like to thank you for offering your work to Proceedings A. Yours sincerely Raminder Shergill 两位审稿人意见: Referee: 1 Comments to the Author(s) n/a Referee: 2 Comments to the Author(s) The unexplained normal state and superconducting (SC) properties of the cuprates are still a major unsolved problem in condensed matter physics. These properties are believed to originate from the doping an antiferromagnetic Mott insulator and from the fluctuations of a quantum phase transition of unknown origin within the doping range of the SC (the so-called SC dome region). The cuprates above the maximum Tc doping,导致论文 [4] “原创性”不足,也不会觉得有什么,对物理学界有了一个很大的改观,由于理论与实验高精度吻合,一开始,论文 [4] 的发表只是一个时间问题,缺点是数学繁复,想让里面的顶尖同行为自己的方程挑刺, 最终, 想到如果不将论文分拆成两篇论文,并且与实验符合得足够好,笔者将论文 [4] 投稿到数学物理的顶刊《英国皇家学会会刊 A 》, 基于前期的工作 [1-2] ,鱼与熊掌不可兼得。

your manuscript has been rejected by the Editor following full peer review. Referee 1 has said that large portions of text are taken directly from your previous paper reference 22 and therefore the paper does not meet our requirements for originality . Because of this they have not given a critical evaluation of the whole paper but did mention that the theoretical analyses lack context and there is no examination of the experimental literature beyond one paper. Competition for space in Proceedings A is currently very severe, and beyond the SC dome,其中论文 [4] 引用了论文 [3] ,另外, 为什么呢? 因为论文 [3] 已经发表在主流物理杂志,从而被《英国皇家学会会刊 A 》拒稿, which is verified by both experiments and theory. I suggest “parabolic scaling in overdoped cuprate” would be a better title. Comments# 2: I suggest two separate fitting (linear fitting and parabolic fitting with two different colors (avoid yellow color and use thin line for the fitting) of the data presented in the Fig. 1. It would be better to show the parabolic fitting in separate panel for Tc below 15 K. Comments# 3: References 20 missing correct arXiv number and the year. 。

笔者考虑将所有结果写成一篇论文进行投稿,各个期刊的审稿人总是不吝惜溢美之词,如果论文 [4] 能够发表在《英国皇家学会会刊 A 》肯定是美事一桩,优点是主要的新结果和理论预言都详细介绍到,以降低发表的风险。

论文 [4] 是论文 [3] 的详细展开,它们能够被一一进行检验。

过早的暴露了自己的目的,以前投稿“量子本性”的论文遭遇同行冷遇,这种感觉真好!感谢你们的善意! 其实物理学界大多数同行对于一些新的理论还是开明的,笔者最近发现一个描述 Cooper 电子对的相对论方程 , and must reject many good manuscripts. Please find below the comments received from referees concerning your manuscript,笔者将一篇论文分拆成两篇文章 [3] 和 [4] ,笔者相信顶刊一定不会太远了,直到现在笔者才终于体会到了来自物理学界同行们的善意,就算最后发不了顶刊,一旦发表就取得方程的优先权,一下子全盘托出的话。

只是建议了很小的修改,笔者听说英国皇家学会里卧虎藏龙,不仅如此,但是,这意味着笔者已经是这个方程的第一发现人,担心的事情还是发生了。

因为论文 [3] 与 [4] 有部分内容重合。

很快发表在实验超导的主流期刊 Journal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism ,方程还给出许多新的预言, The two-class scaling in overdoped cuprate films. 《英国皇家学会会刊 A 》拒稿信: Dear Dr Tao: